Showing posts with label Redistricting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Redistricting. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 12, 2012

Redistricting the Montana legislature -- surprise... Democrats get much of what they want

There are some mixed messages in Mike Dennison's recent article on legislative redistricting. The headline reads that the GOP is "looking hard to beat." Yet that hardly describes the reality as outlined in the article itself.

It seems that what happened in the redistricting process is that the rural-urban divide favored by Republicans (and common sense) prevailed, so rural districts will not be diluted by urban precincts that tend to be more Democratic. On the other hand, it appears that districts within the cities themselves were drawn according to the principles of Democratic gerrymandering expert Joe Lamson. Lamson believes that districts should be drawn in such a way that give Democrats the best chance of winning control of the state legislature. At least he's honest about it.

What this means is that in a city like Billings, Democratic leaning precincts will be mixed in with Republican leaning precincts to create districts in such a way as to give Democrats the most winnable districts. Whether a legislator (of either party) who narrowly wins such districts can do a good job of representing all of his constituents is quite another question.

The Democrats also appeared to have won significant victories in the creation of Senate districts, since Dennison says that Republicans will have "42-47 relatively safe seats in the House, and another six or seven that clearly lean Republican... (while) Democrats can probably count on 32-39 House seats as safe, and another seven that lean Democratic." In the Senate, however, Republicans will have 21 safe seats, while Democrats have 19 or 20 safe seats. Translation: Senate districts have been created by often pairing Democratic House districts with Republican house districts in a way that gives Democrats an edge.

Republican member of the redistricting commission Jon Bennion has this to say:

“As the plan stands now, Republicans would certainly lose seats in the House, not because of their ideas or their candidates, but simply because of lines that were drawn based on political data and election results..."

While the gerrymandering was not as bold and in-your-face as it was 10 years ago, it appears that Democrats have again made significant gains with the help of the redistricting commission. The losers will again be those Montanans who find themselves thrown into districts where the lines were drawn to give Democrats a shot at winning, rather than according to principles of similar constituent interests.

The silver lining? Montana Republicans were dealt about as bad a hand in the last redistricting as possible -- and yet, in all but the 2004 election, they managed, through dint of sheer effort, to win control of one or both legislative bodies. Even the 2004 election was stolen from them by the Montana Supreme Court. It wasn't enough that the Supreme Court handed the redistricting commission to the Democratic Party -- they also had to step in and hand a decisive contested seat to the Democrats by fiat, under the most specious of reasoning.

In short, while Republicans have again been dealt an unfair hand in the current redistricting, they will have their destiny in their own hands. If they recruit strong candidates who work hard and smart -- both in campaigning and in serving their constituents in Helena, Republicans should be able to control the legislature more often than not. If Republicans act with (ahem) indiscretion in Helena and run candidates who are looney, lazy, or both, then Democratic governor Steve Bullock may soon have a Democratic legislature with whom he can partner to run the state into the ground...

Wednesday, November 28, 2012

Redistricting Montana's legislature

It seems that the legislative redistricting wrangling isn't quite done. The process has been relatively quiet, and as I understand, the heavy lifting (the House districts) has already been completed, with the remaining task being to pair up the 100 House districts to create 50 Senate districts. We've waxed eloquent on this general topic many times before, but why not a little more?

As per usual, the general breakdown is this:

a. Montana Republicans want districts to follow traditional dividing lines like county boundaries, school district boundaries, and city limits as much as possible and to have districts be relatively homogenous, allowing representatives to be more likely to be truly representative of their districts.

b. Montana Democrats want the goal of redistricting to be to give Democrats the best possible chance of gaining a majority.

To be fair, Republicans also want to be in the majority, but really, all they need to do to achieve that in a state like Montana is:

a. Don't gerrymander the districts.

b. Don't act like idiots (either personally or politically) once they get to Helena.

Since item "b" is by no means out of the question, Democrats can still gain majorities in the state legislature without gerrymandering the districts like they did 10 years ago with the connivance of the Montana Supreme Court, but I can certainly see why they would prefer not to have to depend on Republican screw-ups to have a shot at controlling a legislative body.

Still, that is the reality of life for Republicans in heavily Democratic states, so in my opinion, that's life. Democrats have completely dominated Montana's U.S. Senate elections in the modern era -- should we adopt rules that make it equally likely for a Republican to be elected to the U.S. Senate in Montana? We could call it the "Dan Cox rule." In one election, a Libertarian candidate would run, with his campaign quietly funded by Democrats. In the next election, conservative third-party candidates would be banned, while we would have a Green Party candidate who is quietly funded by Republicans.

Alternatively, we could have a law requiring Democratic and Republican U.S. Senate candidates to say and do one equally off-putting thing for anything off-putting that the opposing candidate does. Democrats can take a turn berating forest fire-fighters or suing a local government for a change. Sen. Baucus could be required to take contributions from Jack Abramoff (oh, wait, he already did that -- maybe the law would also have to require the Montana press to run stories about it on a daily basis.)

Senator Baucus could be required to pay a "Finance Committee Chairman Tax" whereby he is required to give half of his Wall Street and K-Street donations to his Republican opponent. Republicans running for the U.S. Congressional seat could be required to wear funny hats at every public appearance until a Democrat finally wins again.

Or we could just skip elections entirely and just have the opposing parties choose the Senators every other term -- and Libertarians could choose the Senator 5% of the time (doing the math in my head, about once every 110 years?) That sort of thing.

Am I being facetious? Of course. But mandating such things makes no less sense than does mandating gerrymandered districts with the sole goal of giving Democrats a better chance of winning majorities in Helena.

On philosophical and historical grounds, I think that Republicans have by far the better argument. A classic example of redistricting gone bad is Taylor Brown's old district, which stretches from the outskirts of Miles City through to Billings suburbs. What interests do Carbon County ranchers, Billings suburbanites, and Rosebud County union members have in common? When you design a district like that, you are maximizing the chances for a Democratic win in that part of the state, but you are minimizing the chances that the winner (of either party) is going to be a zealous representative of the interests of as many residents as possible.

The whole point to representative government is that the diversity is to be found in the legislative body itself, not within each district. The representatives are, we hope, as representative as possible of their constituents. You don't achieve that by throwing urban voters in with rural ones or by similar redistricting stunts.

It is true that even next-door neighbors can have dramatically different political opinions, but they are likely to have more interests in common than are political opposites in different parts of the state.

If we were to take Democratic logic to its logical conclusion, why not have non-geographical districts? Voting patterns could be analyzed to try to make the breakdown as close as possible. In order to even things out in a Flathead County district, why not throw in a precinct from around Crow Agency? Or to even things out in Butte, pair a couple precincts from there with a couple from southeastern Montana. Really, if we don't care about whether the eventual representative really represents the district, and only about giving Democrats the best chance of winning a majority, why bother with district boundaries at all?

So far, the process has been going far better than ten years ago, when the parents (the Montana Supreme Court) handed the keys to the teenager (Democrat gerrymandering expert-extraordinaire Joe Lamson) and said in effect, "have fun, come home whenever you want, and don't worry about being safe -- in fact, here's some extra money for booze!"

Wednesday, May 16, 2012

Montana legislative redistricting -- same song, second verse... ("Muskrat Love?")

It's Wednesday, and time for a little Montana politics.

It has been ten years in the brewing, but the kettle is beginning to boil a bit more briskly on that decennial exercise known as legislative redistricting. We have waxed eloquent on the subject before, here, here, and here.

Tom Lutey's article in today's Gazette peers into the process that is currently under way. Once again, just as a decade ago, the non-partisan staffers did their best in doing the legwork of drawing up reasonable boundaries that meet both the requirements of Montana law and the sniff-test of common sense. Once again, Republicans seem to be content with the results and once again, Joe Lamson (this time actually a member of the commission) has drawn up an alternative plan more favorable to Democrats.

While there has been no direct MH examination of the proposed districts or the details surrounding the process, one gets the impression that Democrats realized that they seriously over-reached ten years ago when they captured that redistricting commission, courtesy of the Montana Supreme Court's appointment of a supposedly neutral 5th member -- who wasn't. Back then, they completely threw out the primary working plan created by staffers (as well as all of the alternative plans) and substituted one drawn up by Lamson, one with gerrymandered districts. Take a look at the famous Senate District 22, that ranges from the Billings suburbs to the outskirts of Miles City, or the even more famous "Muskrat Love" Senate District 16. OK, so it was called the "Muskrat District" because of its shape, but the Democrats apparently did "love" it, so why not a little blast from the past? (No, the Captain and Tennille didn't record it first.)

The current working plan, which basically gets a "good enough" vote from Republicans, Lutey reports as being called the "urban-rural" plan. It mostly follows things like county lines, school district lines, and city council district lines. The clue that Democrats know that they aren't going to be able to get as much this time is provided by the fact that their proposed districts this time vary only by a few percentage points, whereas their plan 10 years ago was designed to get the maximum variation (5 percent either way, allowing Republican-leaning districts to be packed with 10% more voters than Democratic-leaning districts) when it was advantageous to do so.

Yellowstone County and Billings city officials spoke in favor of the urban-rural plan, which was similar to a plan the two governments drew up with help from the Billings Chamber of Commerce several months ago. That plan kept all legislative districts within county lines and generally kept Billings’s districts within Billings.

Let us hope that reason prevails and that the neutral 5th member this year is actually neutral. There is, no doubt, room to do some tweaking here and there to improve the working "urban-rural" plan, but if it is thrown out completely for Lamson's alternative plan...

The stakes are high, and not just for purposes of partisanship, since districts that reflect life as it actually is will provide better representation for the members of that district:

Connie Wardell, a School District 2 board member, said her school district, with a student population larger than the individual populations of 44 counties, needed lawmakers who weren’t serving constituents outside of the immediate Billings area.

“Rarely do schools weigh in, but part of the issue we have with funding now is that our delegation is pulled into other counties,” Wardell said. She supported the urban-rural plan for mostly keeping districts within county and city limits.