Wednesday, September 3, 2008

Rich Lowry nails it regarding the left's reaction to Gov. Sarah Palin

Great article. Read it.

The virulence of the reaction of the left and the personal tone that the feeding frenzy has taken is indeed largely culturally-based. Even out here in fly-over land (Lowry notes that Palin is in a part of the U.S. so remote that it technically isn't even in fly-over country,) the criticism seems to reflect a desire to want to mimic the rhetoric of the coastal leftish political smart set.

All of this is irrelevant, though. Can Sarah Palin do the job of being Vice President, and President if need be? Absolutely. One need go no further back than the most recent Presidential election: she is far more ready than John Edwards was in 2004, a man who had one undistinguished term in the U.S. Senate and who hardly showed up for that job, since he was too busy running for President.

Now that we think about it, John Edwards in 2004 was more qualified to be President than Barack Obama is in 2008 -- he had spent 6 years in the Senate with his primary job being running for President, while Sen. Obama has only spent 3 1/2 years in the Senate with his primary job being running for President.

The real question is this, and Lowry is not alone in pointing it out: can Gov. Palin withstand the rigors of the campaign trail in a national campaign? No one knows, and there is no way that anyone can know, until we see how she performs. If she handles herself with poise and confidence and if the McCain staff does a good job of running her part of the campaign, then the McCain/Palin ticket has an excellent chance of winning the election.

If she tanks, they could be on the receiving end of a blowout. Montana Headlines, like conservatives across the country, is rooting for her, but sympathy isn't enough -- she will need to perform well. Somehow, we suspect that she will. Much is made of whether the McCain camp vetted Palin sufficiently. They did, and they knew exactly what they were getting. Taking a chance? Absolutely, but McCain's team was smart enough to know that they weren't going to win this election if they played things safe. Good for them.

Update: a commenter brought attention to this piece by Peggy Noonan, who likewise nails it. Out of many great passages in this piece, one of the best is this, where after listing many of her manifestly attractive qualities, Noonan continues:

...conservatives can smell this sort of thing -- who is really one of them and who is not -- and will fight to the death for one of their beleaguered own; because of all of this she is a real and present danger to the American left, and to the Obama candidacy.

She could become a transformative political presence.

So they are going to have to kill her, and kill her quick.

And it's going to be brutal. It's already getting there.


Read the whole thing. Especially her plain-spoken words to those who are dragging Palin's daughter through the mud.

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

Peggy Noonan also has some interesting insights along similar lines about Palin, McCain and the media in her column today at:
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122044753790594947.html?
mod=rss_opinion_main

Montana Headlines said...

That had to be one of the best pieces I've read in some time -- thanks for bringing it up. It is going to go into the post as an update.

Wulfgar said...

Hmmm. That doesn't seem to be what Peggy Noonan really thinks ...

Montana Headlines said...

Read Noonan's piece -- she spends quite some time talking about how easy it is for insiders like her to lose touch with the real world.

In light of what you wrote, her piece sounds like a confession comparing her initial reaction to a more considered opinion after reflection.

Don't assume that someone's initial outburst is what they "really think." Unless you don't believe that women like Noonan are capable of rational thought and reconsideration.

(Sorry, just kidding -- I know you don't have a condescending bone in your body.)

Montana Headlines said...

Upon review, I see that the live mike episode happened after her piece came out.

What this really tells me is that while Noonan can correctly diagnose the problems that come with being a Washington insider, she still just can't help being one anyway.

As I said above, it is all going to come down to how well Palin performs. There will be no middle ground on this one. Most of you on the left have decided that it is already an unmitigated disaster (and some on the right agree -- but then, I thought that Romney, the supposed safe choice, would have been an unmitigated disaster and sure loser for the Republcans.)

So, the logical thing for you to do is to stop paying attention to the Presidential race, right? I mean, it's over and there is no way that McCain and Palin can win, right?

Anonymous said...

I'm not sure that Wulfgar ever read Noonan's explanation -- a later addition to her column -- of how her conversation with Murphy was taken out of context.

(She says the "It's over" comment was not referring to the McCain campaign but to something else she and Murphy were talking about. You'll notice that the transcript conveniently cuts off the lead-in to that part of the conversation).

Montana Headlines said...

No, Wulfgar hasn't been back to discuss that part of it. Noonan's explanation fits with her public comments much more believably than does the liberal blogosphere distortion of her words.

Those who are interested can go to the WSJ Online, and see Noonan's article with her new header paragraphs that explain the distortion.

Anonymous said...

Another thing that was interesting about that episode is that the "hot mic" belonged to MSNBC. The recording was leaked within an hour or two to some liberal bloggers. That underscores MSNBC's reputation as nothing more than a PR wing of the Democratic party, doesn't it? If I were Noonan, I don't know that I'd ever want to go back on MSNBC again. Someone working there really took advantage of her.